Retired Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Antonio T. Carpio has expressed readiness to participate in a public “friendly debate” regarding the legality of the West Philippine Sea and the Philippines’ maritime entitlements.
In an interview on Isyu Spotted (10 February 2026), Carpio said he is willing to engage in a live discussion to address statements questioning both the legal existence of the West Philippine Sea and the country’s claim over the Kalayaan Island Group.
Clarifying the Legal Issues
Carpio explained that the proposed debate should focus on two central questions:
- Is there a legal basis for the West Philippine Sea under Philippine law?
- Are Philippine islands and maritime features beyond 200 nautical miles still part of national territory and maritime jurisdiction?
He emphasized that these issues are straightforward and can be clarified by referring to existing Philippine laws, maritime baselines, and established principles of international law.
“We cannot allow misinformation to go unanswered,” Carpio said, noting that public discussion is necessary to educate Filipinos on the legal foundations of the country’s maritime claims.
Debate as Public Education
While some observers have questioned the value of holding a debate, Carpio maintained that an open forum would serve an educational purpose. He stressed that arbitration, legal interpretation, and territorial claims should be discussed based on statutes, historical records, and international jurisprudence—not on rhetoric.
Asked whether his offer has an expiration date, Carpio replied that he remains open to the discussion at any time, pending confirmation from the other side.
The former magistrate reiterated that the legal questions surrounding the West Philippine Sea can be addressed clearly and concisely under Philippine law and international maritime principles.
🎥 Watch the full interview here: