Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio emphasizes that the Philippines should seek damages from China due to its ‘hit-and-run’ actions in the West Philippine Sea. According to him, this precedent has significant implications for the country’s claim over disputed territories.
Carpio stresses that international law is clear on the matter: a state cannot claim sovereignty over a territory unless it exercises effective control and demonstrates a genuine interest in the area. China’s actions in the WPS, Carpio argues, do not meet these criteria.
He notes that the Philippines has consistently sought to resolve its disputes with China through peaceful means, including arbitration at The Hague. However, China’s refusal to engage in this process has left Manila with no choice but to pursue other options.
Carpio’s stance on the issue highlights the need for the Philippines to assert its rights and interests in the WPS. By seeking damages from China, the country can demonstrate its commitment to upholding international law and protecting its territorial integrity.