Videos

• Justice Carpio Corrects Duterte’s Misinformation on Hague Tribunal

  28 July 2021

  Tags Antonio Carpio, Carpio on West Philippine Sea dispute, customary international law, Duterte administration, Hague tribunal, Supreme Court Justice

  Retired Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio has set the record straight on a contentious issue in the West Philippine Sea case. In his State of the Nation Address, President Rodrigo Duterte claimed that the Hague tribunal allegedly did not hear China’s position during the proceedings.

  However, according to Justice Carpio, this claim is ‘totally false.’ He explained that the Hague tribunal indeed heard and considered China’s submissions on the matter. The retired justice emphasized that the tribunal’s decision was based on a thorough examination of all relevant evidence presented by both parties.

  In light of Duterte’s statement, Carpio’s clarification highlights the importance of accurate information in resolving complex disputes like the one over the West Philippine Sea. His insight is crucial in shedding light on the actual events surrounding the case and its implications for the country.

  Justice Carpio Corrects Misinformation: Hague Tribunal Heard China’s Position

• Justice Carpio Warns of Impeachment Proceedings Against Duterte Over WPS Issue

  16 July 2021

  Tags Antonio Carpio, ASEAN Sovereignty, Carpio on West Philippine Sea dispute, Constitutional Law, Impeachment Proceedings, Maritime Territorial Integrity, President Rodrigo Duterte

  Retired Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio has expressed concerns that President Rodrigo Duterte may face impeachment proceedings due to his failure to protect the West Philippine Sea. According to Carpio, the Constitution mandates the government to defend the country’s territorial rights, and Duterte’s inaction constitutes a breach of this duty.

  Carpio pointed out that the government’s inaction has allowed China to continue its aggressive expansion in the region, putting the Philippines’ sovereignty at risk. He emphasized that the President’s failure to enforce the Constitution is a ground for impeachment under Article XI of the 1987 Charter.

  The Palace, however, dismissed Carpio’s claims, insisting that Duterte has not violated any constitutional provision. The administration maintained that it is committed to defending the country’s territorial integrity and sovereignty.

  Justice Carpio warns of impeachment proceedings against President Duterte over WPS issue

• Justice Carpio Clarifies PH’s Options Against China’s WPS Fishing

  15 July 2021

  Tags Antonio Carpio, China-Philippines dispute, International Law, Maritime Law, The South China Sea / West Philippine Sea Dispute, UNCLOS

  Retired Supreme Court Associate Justice and 1Sambayan convenor Antonio Carpio recently weighed in on the Philippines’ options against China’s continued fishing activities within the West Philippine Sea (WPS). According to Carpio, the Philippine government can take legal action against China under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) if they continue to disregard their rights and freedoms.

  In a statement that highlights the pressing need for assertive diplomacy in protecting the country’s maritime interests, Carpio emphasized that the Philippines is not helpless in the face of Chinese aggression. By exercising its rights under UNCLOS, the government can bring international pressure to bear on China and hold them accountable for their actions.

  This stance by Justice Carpio underscores the complexity of the issue at hand, which goes beyond mere territorial disputes and involves a broader discussion on international law and sovereignty.

  Justice Carpio: PH has options against China’s WPS fishing

• Carpio: Misconceptions on Joint Development with China Debunked

  15 July 2021

  Tags Carpio on West Philippine Sea dispute, China-Philippines relations, Cooperation Arrangement, Honorable Justice Antonio Carpio, Joint Development, Sovereignty Claims

  Former Supreme Court Justice Antonio Carpio has clarified his stance on the contentious issue of joint development in the West Philippine Sea, stressing that he does not advocate for a joint development arrangement with China. Instead, he is in favor of a cooperation agreement that recognizes the Philippines’ ownership over the area’s oil and gas resources.

  In an effort to dispel misconceptions surrounding his position, Justice Carpio emphasized that any form of joint development would imply shared sovereignty and equal rights for both parties involved. This, he argued, would be tantamount to recognizing China’s claims in the region, which is unacceptable given the Philippines’ historical and legal claims.

  On the other hand, a cooperation arrangement based on mutual respect and understanding could pave the way for a more equitable sharing of resources. By doing so, it would align with the country’s long-held stance that the West Philippine Sea’s oil and gas reserves are rightfully its own.

  Carpio Debunks Misconceptions on Joint Development in West Philippine Sea

• Carpio on Duterte’s China Pact: A Constitutional Conundrum

  15 July 2021

  Tags Antonio Carpio, ASEAN Sovereignty, Carpio on West Philippine Sea dispute, China-PH Relations, Duterte administration, Exclusive Economic Zone, Maritime Territorial Integrity

  Former Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio has thrown a constitutional spanner into the works of President Duterte’s administration. The retired justice has argued that the president’s agreement with China to allow its fishermen in the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone (EEZ) is a clear infringement on the country’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.

  Carpio, known for his uncompromising stance on issues related to the West Philippine Sea, believes that the president’s actions are tantamount to an unconstitutional surrender of national patrimony. He points out that the Constitution clearly prohibits foreign entities from fishing within the EEZ without the consent of the Philippine government.

  The implications of this agreement are far-reaching and have sparked heated debates among lawmakers, legal experts, and the general public. With Carpio’s sharp analysis and critical eye on the situation, it remains to be seen how the administration will respond to these constitutional concerns.

  Carpio blasts Duterte’s China pact as a clear violation of Philippine sovereignty

• Philippines Can Pursue UNCLOS Arbitration Against China for WPS Fishing Activities, Says Justice Carpio

  15 July 2021

  Tags Antonio Carpio, Carpio on West Philippine Sea dispute, China’s Maritime Assertiveness, Regional security, UNCLOS

  Retired Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio emphasizes that the Philippines has a legitimate claim against China for fishing in the West Philippine Sea (WPS). According to him, the country can take legal action by filing a complaint with the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) tribunal if Chinese vessels continue to engage in such activities. This assertion comes amidst ongoing concerns over Beijing’s maritime assertiveness and its implications for regional security.

  Justice Carpio: PH Can Pursue UNCLOS Arbitration Against China for WPS Fishing Activities

• Justice Carpio’s Call to Action: Why a Revised Baselines Law Matters for West Philippine Sea Sovereignty

  06 July 2021

  Tags ASEAN Sovereignty, Baselines Law, Carpio on West Philippine Sea dispute, Economic Development, Honorable Justice Antonio Carpio, Maritime Governance, National Security, UNCLOS

  As the West Philippine Sea continues to be a contentious issue, one expert opinion stands out in emphasizing the need for an amended baselines law. Justice Antonio Carpio, a respected jurist and vocal advocate for national sovereignty, has highlighted the importance of such legislation in ensuring effective enforcement of the country’s rights under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).

  In a recent exchange with his colleague, retired Associate Justice Francis Jardeleza, Carpio underscored the practicality and necessity of passing a new law establishing definitive baselines in the West Philippine Sea. This move, he argues, would provide clarity and legal certainty for the Philippines’ claims to its maritime territories.

  By revising the current baselines law, the country can better assert its rights over its territorial waters and resources, while also preventing potential conflicts with neighboring countries. As Justice Carpio emphasizes, a clear and consistent approach to establishing baselines would help to prevent disputes and foster greater cooperation in the region.

  The call for an amended baselines law has sparked renewed interest in the Philippines’ maritime governance. With its rich natural resources and strategic location, the West Philippine Sea is a vital area of concern for national security and economic development. By supporting Justice Carpio’s position, citizens can contribute to upholding the country’s sovereignty and ensuring the long-term sustainability of its marine environment.

  Justice Antonio Carpio pushes for revised baselines law to assert Philippine sovereignty over West Philippine Sea

• Carpio-led Coalition Vows to Halt Philippines’ Passive Stance on Sovereignty

  12 June 2021

  Tags 1Sambayan Coalition, Antonio Carpio, ASEAN Sovereignty, Carpio on West Philippine Sea dispute, Philippine Politics, Philippine Territorial Disputes

  As the territorial dispute over the West Philippine Sea continues to pose a significant threat to the nation’s sovereignty, former Associate Justice Antonio Carpio has expressed strong criticism towards the current administration’s inadequate response. According to Carpio, the government’s reluctance to assert its claims and defend its territory is not only unpatriotic but also detrimental to the country’s long-term interests.

  Carpio, who serves as a key figure in the opposition coalition 1Sambayan, has reaffirmed his commitment to addressing this pressing issue. He emphasized that the coalition will work tirelessly to ensure that the Philippines’ sovereignty is upheld and its rights are respected.

  The former Justice pointed out that the current administration’s refusal to defend the country’s claims in the West Philippine Sea is a manifestation of its lack of resolve and dedication to protecting the nation’s interests. He underscored the need for strong leadership and decisive action to safeguard the Philippines’ sovereignty and territorial integrity.

  Carpio-led coalition vows to halt Philippines’ passive stance on sovereignty